Is it Worth Buying a Cat S Car? A Realistic Breakdown

If you’ve come across a surprisingly cheap used car with “Cat S” on its history, you’re probably wondering what the catch is.

Category S (short for “Structural”) means the car was written off by an insurer after sustaining damage to its structural frame, but has since been repaired and put back on the road.

So, is it a clever bargain or a risky bet?

This guide breaks down what Cat S actually means, the risks you need to be aware of and how to decide whether buying one is the right move for you.

What is a Cat S car?

A Cat S car is a vehicle that’s been written off by an insurance company due to structural damage. The “S” stands for “Structural”, meaning the damage affected key parts of the car’s frame (such as the chassis or crumple zones).

Technically, Cat S cars can be repaired and put back on the road, but they must be re-registered with the DVLA before being driven again. Unlike Cat A or B cars (which are too damaged to return to the road), a Cat S write-off could still be roadworthy if it’s properly repaired.

Why do people consider buying Cat S cars?

At first glance, a Cat S label might sound like a total deal-breaker. But many buyers see it as an opportunity. The important thing to understand is that a Cat S car was written off because it wasn’t worth repairing for the insurer, not necessarily because it was totally beyond repair.

That decision could be based on a number of factors:

• The cost of labour and parts was too high
• The car’s market value was relatively low
• The insurer wanted a fast payout without repair delays
• The damage, while structural, wasn’t especially complex

The vehicle is clearly not roadworthy right after the accident, but it can be repaired and made safe again. Once that happens, it can legally go back on the road. However, even after full repairs, the car will always carry the Cat S label on its record, which raises doubts about the quality of repairs.

So, why do some buyers take the chance? The main reason to buy a Cat S car is cost savings. You’ll pay 20-40% less than you would for identical models with a clean history because of the car’s salvage history.

The risks of buying a Cat S vehicle

It’s not illegal to drive a Cat S car once it’s been made roadworthy, but the structural damage means it’s not like buying a regular used car. You’ll need to do more due diligence to make sure the repairs were done to a high standard. There is a reason they sell for less than market price, after all.

Safety concerns

The biggest risk is structural integrity. If the repairs weren’t done to a professional standard, the car may not protect you properly in another accident. Or, a parts failure from shoddy repair work could get you into one.

There’s no legal requirement for Cat S cars to undergo independent structural inspections after repair. So unless you’re given photos, receipts and an inspection report as evidence, you’re taking someone’s word that the work was done right.

Resale struggles

Cat S status sticks with the car for life, and it’s a red flag for most buyers. Even if the car drives perfectly, many will walk away the moment they see “Cat S” on the logbook. That means longer selling times, lower offers and limited interest on platforms like Auto Trader or Facebook Marketplace.

Insurance issues

Some insurers won’t cover Cat S cars at all because of the added risk. Others will, but at a higher premium.

That’s because they see the vehicle as a higher risk, both in terms of potential failure and difficulty assessing value. You may also run into trouble getting a payout if your insurer questions the repair quality after a future claim.

Hidden costs

What looks like a bargain can quickly become a money pit. You might uncover repair shortcuts, lingering mechanical issues, or poor alignment once you start driving. These are things you’ll have to fix on your own. And if the repair work was done without manufacturer-approved parts or processes, you could void any remaining warranty and create long-term reliability issues.

The advantages of buying a Cat S car

Despite the risks, there are valid reasons why buyers go for Cat S vehicles—especially in a tight or overpriced market.

Lower purchase price

The most obvious advantage is the price. On average, Cat S cars can sell for 20-40% less than similar models with a clean history. It’s a fantastic way to save money if you’re strapped for cash or the current second-hand market is expensive.

Trade to trade car marketplace

• Trade-only marketplace
• Flexible selling options
• Maximise your profits

Sign up now

4.9 out of 5 Stars

More car for your money

If the car has been properly repaired, you might be getting a well-equipped vehicle in great condition for thousands less. And with the steep discount, that puts better makes, newer models, or lower mileage vehicles within reach for buyers who might otherwise be priced out.

Opportunity for skilled buyers

If you’re mechanically experienced or know a trustworthy mechanic, you can vet the repairs yourself or even take on light work if the car needs further attention. This gives you more control over the outcome and helps ensure the car is safe, making it a less risky buy.

Great for short-term use

If you only need a car for a couple of years, a Cat S vehicle might make sense. The lower upfront cost offsets the weaker resale value, especially if you plan to drive it into the ground rather than flip it later. And you’re probably less worried about the potential long-term issues.

How to check if a Cat S car is safe to buy

If you're thinking about buying a Cat S car, you need to do more homework than usual. Since the car’s been structurally damaged and repaired, you can’t just take it at face value.

1. Check the MOT history.

This is something you can do right now, for free. Look for any unusual advisories or failures related to suspension, steering, alignment, or bodywork. A spotty MOT history suggests the car wasn’t fully sorted before or after the accident.

2. Review the HPI report.

Unlike the free checks you can do on gov.uk, an HPI check reveals hidden issues that don’t show up on basic records. This includes:

• Whether the car was previously written off and the specific category (S, N, etc.)
• Outstanding finance, which could lead to repossession
• Whether the car’s ever been reported stolen
• Mileage discrepancies that suggest tampering
• If the vehicle was ever scrapped, imported, or exported

It’s worth paying for because these hidden details can affect your legal ownership, your safety and your ability to resell the car later. If there’s outstanding finance, you don’t fully own the car. If it was stolen or badly repaired, you could be putting yourself at risk. And if the mileage doesn’t match up, you might be overpaying for a car that’s been clocked.

3. Inspect the car yourself.

When you go to see the car in person, there are quite a few things you’ll want to check inside, around and underneath the car. We’ve prepared a quick checklist you can use when you arrive to take that first look.

4. Get a professional inspection.

Always get the car inspected by an independent mechanic or vehicle assessor, ideally someone with experience in crash repair work. They’ll check the quality of the repairs, the alignment and any signs of hidden damage. You can also request a structural report or a vehicle engineer's certificate if the seller has one.

5. Ask for repair documentation.

Reputable sellers should be able to show:

• Before and after photos
• Invoices for parts and labour
• Details of the repair shop or technician who carried out the work

No paperwork? Walk away. It’s too risky without proof the job was done properly.

6. Test drive it thoroughly.

On your test drive, listen for unusual noises, pulling to one side, or anything that feels “off”. Pay close attention to how it handles corners and bumps as well, because that usually points to poor structural repairs.

What about finance and insurance on Cat S vehicles?

Financing a Cat S car

Financing a Cat S car isn’t impossible, but it’s definitely harder.

Most mainstream lenders avoid salvage-title vehicles altogether because they see them as higher risk and harder to value accurately. If finance is available, it usually comes through specialist lenders who deal with non-standard vehicles, and they’ll charge higher interest rates to offset the risk.

In most cases, the cleanest option is to pay in cash. You’re already getting a steep discount on the vehicle, and that way, you avoid the financing hassle and start with full ownership from day one.

Insuring a Cat S car

Insuring a Cat S car is more doable by a huge margin, but it’s not always straightforward. Some insurers will refuse to quote. Others will insure it but with higher premiums, because they consider the car harder to assess and more expensive to settle if something goes wrong.

When you’re looking for insurance cover, make sure to get quotes before you buy the car. Disclose the Cat S status up front (if you don’t, they might void your policy) and shop around; some insurers are more flexible with salvage vehicles than others.

Maybe it goes without saying, but expect to pay more than you would for the same model with a clean history.

Expert tips if you still want to buy a Cat S car

If, after reading up to this point, you’re going to buy a Cat S vehicle, do it with both eyes open. To help you, here are a few of our insider-level tips that’ll help you get the most out of your purchase:

1. Buy from a dealer who specialises in salvage.

Avoid private sellers unless they’ve got an impeccable paper trail. Go to a dealer that actually specialises in Cat S or salvage cars. They tend to have better documentation, a reputation to protect and access to trade-only repair teams.

The most convenient way to do this is through our platform. We built Trader.co.uk to be a marketplace for Cat S buyers to find trusted sellers. You get the added security of knowing each seller is legit (something you won’t find on Facebook Marketplace), but you don’t even have to get out of bed to find it.

2. Ask to see photos of the pre-repair damage.

Good sellers will have photos of the car before it was fixed. You want to see where it was damaged and how bad it really was. If they won’t show them, assume the worst. If the chassis legs were crumpled, for example, even the best repair might not restore it to factory safety standards.

3. Check the date of the damage vs. the MOT.

Here’s a pro move: cross-reference the write-off date with the MOT history. If the MOT happened shortly after the repairs, see if it passed clean or had advisories that hint at leftover issues. If there's a big time gap with no MOT or usage, ask why. Someone sat on the car, possibly because it was hard to fix or hard to sell.

4. Bring a paint depth gauge.

They’re £20 online and make you look like you know what you're doing. A paint depth gauge will tell you where panels have been resprayed or filled. If one side of the car reads way higher than the rest, that’s where it took the hit. No guesswork needed.

5. If it seems too cheap, remember there’s a catch.

You already know Cat S cars are discounted. But if the price is way under market even for Cat S, there’s probably a reason. Maybe the airbag didn’t deploy properly. Maybe the engine took damage in the crash. Or maybe it wasn’t repaired at all, just cosmetically patched up. Ask yourself: what corners were cut to get it back on the road this cheaply?

6. Don’t bother unless it’s at least 25-30% below market value.

Even though “too” cheap is a red flag, you don’t want to assume any kind of risk unless you’re saving some serious cash. If it’s only 10-15% less than a second-hand car with a clean title, it’s not really worth it to save a few hundred quid.

Is it worth it? Here’s the real bottom line:

A Cat S car is worth it if (and only if) you know what you're doing and you're willing to treat the buying process like an investigation, not a quick deal.

If you're chasing a discount and the car has documented, high-quality repairs, then yes, you’re more than likely getting a solid vehicle for a lot less than market value. But it’s not a shortcut for first-time buyers or anyone who just wants something “cheap and cheerful”.

Final thoughts

Buying a Cat S car isn’t for everyone, and that’s exactly the point. These cars sit in a grey area between risk and reward.

If you know what you’re doing, ask the right questions and don’t mind the stigma, you can walk away with a solid vehicle at a serious discount. But if you’re not confident inspecting repairs, dealing with limited finance options or explaining the Cat S tag when you sell it later, you’re better off sticking to a clean-title car.